Previous determinations

Determinations are made by MBIE on matters of doubt or dispute to do with building work. Rulings are legally binding, but only in relation to each case.

Previous determinations may provide some useful guidance for those faced with similar problems, but note that individual circumstances may vary.

You can also search for Determinations on Building CodeHub

Find a determination

Applying filters will narrow down your search results

Find a determination

Search results

139 Determinations match your query
Show detailed results

2026/046: Regarding compliance of building work with clause E1.3.1 and decisions in relation to that building

This determination considers an authority’s decision to issue a code compliance certificate for building work carried out at 575 Don Buck Road, and whether that building work complies with clause E1 Surface water as it relates to protection of other property. The matter turns on an assessment of whether the building work has concentrated or directed surface water in a way that could cause nuisance or damage at 579 Don Buck Road.

About this document

2026/044: Compliance with E1.3.1 for protection of other property and the refusal to issue a notice to fix

This determination considers whether building work carried out at 6 Oakum Road complies with Clause E1.3.1 in relation to the protection of ‘other property’ and the authority’s decision to refuse to issue a notice to fix. The determination considers whether surface water collected and concentrated by the building work is disposed of in a way that avoids the likelihood of nuisance or damage to 4 Oakum Road.

About this document

2026/038: An authority’s decision to issue a notice to fix for building work to an apartment deck

This determination relates to a notice to fix where the authority considered that work on a Unit’s existing deck and door threshold, and the installation of a new rainwater head and downpipe from the deck, undertaken without a building consent, was building work regulated under the Building Act. The determination also considers the content of the notice to fix.

About this document

2026/036: Regarding the compliance of a modular dwelling with Clauses B1, B2, E1, E2, E3, and G9

This determination considers the compliance of a modular dwelling constructed partly offsite and partly at the owners’ property under two separate building consents granted by two authorities. The determination discusses the compliance of the as-built work with several clauses of the Building Code, primarily relating to the dwelling’s structure, weathertightness, gutters, bathroom linings, and electrical fixtures.

About this document

2025/051: Compliance of an altered retaining wall with B1 Structure and a surface water management system with E1 Surface water

This determination considers whether a retaining wall on two properties complies with the provisions of Building Code Clause B1 Structure following strengthening work and additions, and whether an associated surface water management system complies with Clause E1 Surface water for the protection of other property.

About this document

2025/031: The authority’s decision to refuse to grant a building consent for building work to a relocated dwelling.

This determination examines an authority’s decision to refuse to grant an application for a building consent for building work in relation to relocating and altering an existing dwelling under section 50. The determination evaluates whether the authority’s reasons for refusing to grant the building consent were specific, clear and valid, particularly concerning the natural hazard provisions of the Act, and Clauses B1 Structure, E1 Surface Water and G13 Foul Water.

About this document

2025/029: An authority’s decision to issue three notices to fix for building work done without a building consent.

This determination considers three notices to fix for building work that was carried out without building consent.  The determination considers whether the building work was exempt under Schedule 1 of the Act. It also considers the form and content of the notices to fix, including the particulars of the contraventions and who the notices were issued to.

About this document

2025/023: Regarding the issue of three code compliance certificates and compliance of items of building work

This determination considers the issue of three separate code compliance certificates, related to three different building consents, for building work to make various alterations and additions to an existing detached dwelling. All three building consents were issued under the Building Act 1991. This determination considers if the building work complies with the Building Code that applied at the time the building consents were granted.

About this document

2024/069: Regarding the compliance of building work with Building Code Clause E1 Surface water.

This determination considers whether the building work carried out at 189 Tanners Point Road relating to surface water collection and disposal complies with clause E1.3.1 as it relates to the protection of ‘other property’. This turns on whether surface water collected or concentrated by buildings or sitework at 189 Tanners Point Road avoids the likelihood of damage or nuisance to 195 Tanners Point Road.

About this document

2024/067: Regarding compliance with Clause E1.3.1 as it relates to the protection of 32 and 32A Wolsley Avenue, Milford

This determination concerns building work associated with the construction of four new dwellings. The determination considers the compliance with Clause E1.3.1 of the Building Code in relation to protection of other property from surface water. It also considers the issue of three building consents, and whether there were grounds to issue a notice to fix in relation to the compliance of the building works with Clause E1.3.1.  

About this document

This information is published by the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment’s Chief Executive. It is a general guide only and, if used, does not relieve any person of the obligation to consider any matter to which the information relates according to the circumstances of the particular case. Expert advice may be required in specific circumstances. Where this information relates to assisting people:

Print this page (recommended)

This will print only the current page of this guidance document.

Print this page

Cancel